I Asked 5 AI Chatbots to Pick Stocks. Here’s What Happened Next

Picture this: You’re scrolling through your phone at 11 PM, can’t sleep, and suddenly you have a burning question about whether you should buy NVIDIA stock. Where do you turn? If you’re like millions of people these days, you probably ask ChatGPT or another AI chatbot.

But here’s the thing nobody talks about: these AI models are basically becoming the world’s most popular (and unpaid) financial advisors. And they don’t always agree.

The Great AI Stock-Picking Experiment

So I decided to run a little experiment. I asked five different AI models the exact same question about NVIDIA: “What do you think will happen to NVIDIA’s stock price over the next 3 months, 1 year, and 5 years?”

What happened next was pretty wild.

The Results Were All Over the Map

Check this out:

Claude Sonnet 4: “Eh, it’s going down 5% in the next few months, but long-term? 180% gains over 5 years.”

DeepSeek V3: “Are you kidding? This thing’s going up 10% in three months and 300% over five years!”

Gemini: “Hold my beer. 20% in three months, 75% in one year, 250% in five years.”

GPT-4o: Same as DeepSeek (suspicious much?).

Qwen Max: “Let’s be reasonable here. 15% short-term, 40% in a year, 250% long-term.”

Wait, What Just Happened?

So we’ve got one AI basically saying “sell now, buy later” while another is screaming “buy everything NOW!” These aren’t random number generators we’re talking about. These are sophisticated AI systems that millions of people trust for investment advice.

The craziest part? Claude was the only one brave enough to predict short-term losses. Its reasoning? “Valuation stretched near-term.” Basically AI-speak for “this stock is expensive right now.”

Meanwhile, the other models were like “AI demand go brrrr” and “NVIDIA is basically printing money.”

Each AI Has Its Own Investment Personality

After digging into their responses, it became clear that each AI model has developed its own investing style:

Claude: The cautious value investor. Probably wears suspenders and reads annual reports for fun.

DeepSeek & GPT-4o: The growth-obsessed momentum traders. These guys would buy anything with “AI” in the name.

Gemini: The aggressive day trader who’s convinced they can time the market perfectly.

Qwen: The balanced portfolio manager who actually thinks before hitting buy.

Why This Actually Matters (More Than You Think)

Here’s where things get interesting. Millions of people are asking these AI models for investment advice every single day. And if AI Model A is telling half the world to buy while AI Model B is telling the other half to wait, what happens to the stock price?

We might be looking at the first AI-driven market bubbles and crashes.

Think about it:

• Your trading app might start using AI analysis to suggest stocks
• Robo-advisors could incorporate these AI opinions into their algorithms
• Social media gets flooded with AI-generated investment content
• Suddenly everyone’s making decisions based on what their favorite chatbot thinks

The Scary Smart Analysis

But here’s what really blew my mind: these AI models weren’t just throwing darts at a board. They were doing legitimate financial analysis:

• Talking about price-to-earnings ratios like seasoned analysts
• Discussing competitive threats from AMD and Intel
• Analyzing data center demand and AI infrastructure spending
• Considering Federal Reserve policy impacts

Some of their reasoning was better than what you’d get from your average financial advisor (sorry, financial advisors).

The Real Question: Are We Creating AI Market Manipulation?

Here’s the million-dollar question: If enough people start following AI stock picks, do the AI predictions become self-fulfilling prophecies?

Imagine this scenario:

1. ChatGPT tells a million people to buy XYZ stock
2. A million people buy XYZ stock
3. XYZ stock goes up because of all the buying
4. ChatGPT was “right”
5. More people trust ChatGPT for stock picks
6. Repeat

We could end up in a world where AI models accidentally manipulate markets just by having opinions.

What This Means for Regular Investors

If you’re using AI for investment research (and let’s be honest, who isn’t these days), here are some things to keep in mind:

Don’t just ask one AI: Like getting a second medical opinion, ask multiple models and see where they agree and disagree.

Understand the biases: Each model seems to have its own risk tolerance and analytical style. Figure out which one matches your investing personality.

Remember they’re not fortune tellers: These models are analyzing patterns in data, not predicting the future. Even the smartest AI can be wrong.

Check their work: If an AI gives you a stock recommendation, dig into their reasoning. Does it actually make sense?

The Wild West of AI Investing

We’re basically living in the Wild West of AI-powered investing right now. There are no rules, no regulations, and no one really knows what happens when millions of people start taking stock advice from robots.

For those curious about diving deeper into this rabbit hole, researchers are tracking these AI investment patterns in real-time. One comprehensive analysis of how different AI models view NVIDIA’s prospects shows just how dramatic these differences can be when you look at the data systematically.

The Bottom Line

AI models are quietly becoming some of the most influential voices in investing, whether we intended it or not. They’re sophisticated, they disagree with each other, and millions of people are listening to them.

The question isn’t whether AI will change how we invest. It’s whether we’ll figure out how to use these powerful tools wisely before they accidentally break something.

In the meantime, maybe don’t bet your retirement fund on what ChatGPT thinks about meme stocks. Just a thought.

---

Remember: AI models, no matter how smart they sound, aren’t licensed financial advisors. They’re really good at pattern recognition, but they can’t predict the future. Always do your own research and talk to real human professionals before making big money moves.